“The advent of the computer generated the phenomena called desktop publishing. This enabled anyone who could type the freedom of using any available typeface and do any kind of distortion. It was a disaster of mega proportions. A cultural pollution of incomparable dimension. As I said, at the time, if all people doing desktop publishing were doctors we would all be dead!”Massimo Vignelli, The Vignelli Canon p. 52.
5 comments
Whatever. The printing press had its detractors too, both from the “craftsman” point of view and those who were worried about “keeping the Word of God unsullied by the unwashed masses.” Like any technology, it can be used well or used poorly, but it feels more a little snobbish to say that it’s “cultural pollution of incomparable dimension” because my mom can now put out a newsletter exclusively using Comic Sans and Curlz :-)
comment by Ted 2 hours later
Quotes like this just are so off the wall and short-sighted. Great designer does not not necessarily equal great analyst.
comment by Sam one day later
Ted and Sam: you guys really have to read this in the context of how it is written in his book.
I think the quote is brilliant. If I remember correctly, Vignelli begins by talking about “noise” pollution something that nearly every metropolis and large city deals with and has ordinances to control. Noise pollution comes from something being too loud, out of harmony, and out of place. Visual pollution is the same type of thing. When you display visual elements that are out of place, not in harmony, too loud, and don’t respect established laws of design, it is no different, and creates “Visual Pollution.”
His point here is the same as what would happen if all the sudden they started playing amateur music compositions in every public setting imaginable. We’d all go nuts.
comment by John Dilworth about a day later
I did read the book, so I do understand the context.
The thought process Vignelli is using is very linear. Design is ever evolving. The pollution (aka product of untrained designers) we see around us does not exist in a vacuum. It both evolved from influence and contributes to the evolution of design. As a whole, the clutter of untrained design will have direct and undeniable influence on the world of design for generations.
If you doubt that, consider the state of the web. Content aside, design and layout on the web owe a HUGE debt of gratitude to the untrained designer.
Whether you agree with me or not, you’ve got to admit that with all of the disgusting behavior that goes on around the world, referring to visual clutter as ‘cultural pollution of incomparable dimension’ is a ridiculous statement. I could think of many many
comment by Sam about a day later
The “context” is that this was written by Massimo Vignelli. Try to imagine a really nice, yet passionate, old guy describing something that really bothers him. Perhaps his language is a bit extreme, but we all lean toward exaggeration in story telling.
Typography is our visual language, and language is at the core of our culture. Giving everyone a tool which allows distortion of our culture is creating cultural pollution, and the dimension (scale) of it is incomparable. I don’t think he’s saying that it is the worst thing in the world, he’s just describing the breadth of the issue.
I think the graphic design I created when I first got my hands on Adobe Illustrator in 1990 would have made Vignelli’s eyes bleed. I think that I could have probably used it as a fatal weapon against him and other modernist designers.
comment by John Dilworth 2 days later
Comment preview
comment by you less than a minute ago