ted boren archives

Where I wish I were in winter…
posted by
ted
on Thursday, Jan 04, 2007
Lessons in interaction design can come from the most unlikely sources—your four year old daughter who has just lost a tooth, for example.
She had been wiggling her first loose tooth for a few days, and it finally came out last night. When telling my wife what she expected under her pillow in return for her tooth, she said in fine alliterative fashion, “I want dollars and diamonds. Cause I’m a girl.” The interaction design lesson? Know your audience and what they want and expect.
The tooth fairy, however, apparently has budget constraints. Supply of lost teeth is high and constantly being replenished, while demand for spare organically grown teeth is quite low. So the tooth fairy did not in fact deliver diamonds nor dollars last night, but rather two shiny quarters. What do we learn for interaction design? Customer requirements must be weighed against budget and timeline; quality design is just one of the elements of a successful project.
Finally, though she did not get what she explicitly asked for, my daughter was thrilled with her silvery coins. You see, “diamonds and dollars” were probably just the words she used to convey her desire for “something shiny and spendable”. Those weren’t her words, but it’s what she meant by them. The interaction design lesson: Customers do not always know what they need, or even what they mean by what they say. It’s our job to take requirements, clarify them, push back to the simplest design that meets those requirements—not to play the Yes-Man to our client.
Thank you, Tooth Fairy, and we’ll see you again soon.
(More design insights from the next visit of the Tooth Fairy…)
posted by
ted
on Wednesday, Jan 03, 2007
“It is better to have a document whose unified character gives it its own dignity and presence than to have a pile of visual odds and ends, each calling attention to itself in a deafening babel of competing typographic voices. Besides, the subject matter ought not to depend on visual cosmetics to fascinate the reader.”
Jan V. White in Graphic Design for the Electronic Age
posted by
ted
on Friday, Dec 29, 2006
UI bloopers in film —a fun review of the ridiculous interfaces of Hollywood. How the cool factor, plot demands, and restriction of the medium contribute to more-than-questionable interface designs in the movies. As Nielsen notes, mostly this doesn’t really matter in terms of real world technology. But he wonders if it influences audience expectations…
He left off one of my favorites: the virus download in Independence Day. Well, the whole film is full of unlikelihoods, starting with Will Smith’s uncanny ability to fly alien craft with no training or mishap other than a minor parking violation. But the human race’s ability to crack the security system of a space-faring race with a killer computer virus, then figure out the interface required to download it is truly astonishing.
posted by
ted
on Monday, Dec 18, 2006
Nice article from Jakob Nielsen comparing and contrasting Progressive and Staged Disclosure as ways to manage complexity and keep things simple for most of your users most of the time. But honestly Jakob—take it easy on the bold text!
posted by
ted
on Monday, Dec 04, 2006
Best article I’ve seen on why you should make links meaningful, instead of the still common “Click Here” approach: Click here to read this article. Tack ska du ha, Emil. (There. I’ve just exhausted what I remember of my mission Swedish.)
posted by
ted
on Monday, Dec 04, 2006
Good for a few chuckles: Announcing Microsoft Firefox 2007. Make sure to read the fine print and advertising for full effect.
posted by
ted
on Monday, Dec 04, 2006

Winter has some great design inspiration…
posted by
ted
on Friday, Dec 01, 2006
Regardless of what you think of Jakob Nielsen’s site design, when Jakob talks, a lot of people in the HCI community listen. His latest AlertBox identifies what he calls three stages of the digital divide: the Economic Divide, the Usability Divide, and the Empowerment Divide. I think we can agree that economics, usability, and user empowerment are all issues on today’s web… but are they all really “divides,” and are they really coming in “stages”?
Aside from the self-serving use of his AlertBox to push the Nielsen Norman Group’s various reports (which are nevertheless often useful and in my opinion reasonably priced), I’ve got some nitpicks with this characterization.
First let’s identify the non-issue: The Economic Divide. It’s real, but as Nielsen points out it is shrinking fast in the developing world as PC costs come down. Nielsen cites a $379 Dell system, well within reach for most American families. Businesses and governments are both working to lower costs even more so that people in impoverished countries have a chance to join in (see all the hoopla about the $100 Computer Project for instance).
So far I agree with Nielsen. Having money makes a difference in gaining access to technology, though this divide is rapidly shrinking. (Hopefully we on the design side won’t erase these gains by bloating sites and software that are intended for the masses, making them unusable for lower end machines and slower networks. No, Jason, I’m not critiquing your post on bigger downloads, since you’ve got an audience on the higher end of technology.)
But then we come to his Second Stage, the Usability Divide. This he describes as “far worse than the economic divide” because most computers remain “so complicated that many people couldn’t use a computer even if they got one for free.” I don’t argue the point that usability is a problem. But for a problem to be a “divide” it must be an issue of “haves” and “have nots”; some people must “have usability” and others must “not have usability.”
Forgive an old English major, but what Nielsen describes is not a usability divide; we’re all plagued with the poor usability on the desktop and on the web. Don’t get me wrong—usability is a barrier to entry for people without experience or education, and we in the industry should lower that barrier. But the fact is that everybody needs (or at least wants) better usability, and not just the uneducated. This is not an issue that divides us. Furthermore, it’s been a problem for a long time; if it’s a stage, it’s been concurrent with the economic stage all along.
Similarly, Nielsen’s Third Stage, the Empowerment Divide, is neither a divide nor a stage. Nielsen states: “Even if computers and the Internet were extraordinarily easy to use, not everybody would make full use of the opportunities that such technology affords.” True enough. People don’t customize their homepage. They don’t sign up for blogs that they might be interested in. They use default services and applications they find on their desktops. They lurk on online communities without contributing. They don’t do a lot of things that we in our wisdom know would be good for them.
But where is the Divide? Are some people unfairly targetted? Are the oppressed masses really unempowered once everything is easy to use? Or is it really the Laziness Divide or the Don’t-Really-Care Divide or the Don’t-Have-Time-to-Optimize Divide? I myself am currently in this last camp; I have a brand new Macbook, chock full of usability and fabulous design, but my transition from my beloved tablet is slow, and not just because I used to work for Microsoft. (Did I just shoot my credibility?) Optimization and personalization and a switch to anything new takes time and energy, which are in short supply right now. It has a cost. Other things (namely my pregnant wife, my two projects about to launch, and my other kids) take precedence over learning a new (if incredibly desireable) OS.
So I guess at this point, if optimization is easy and obvious, there is still such a thing as personal choice, and people will choose to exercise it or not. That’s as it should be. It is not the job of the design or HCI or business community to force people to do good things for themselves. Provide sensible defaults, good value for the money, and a great experience out of the box, all based on sound design and usability principles.
And then to paraphrase Joseph Smith, who knew nothing about computers but a lot about choices, we can only let them govern themselves.
posted by
ted
on Tuesday, Nov 21, 2006
“Quotation, n: The act of repeating erroneously the words of another.”
Ambrose Bierce, via The Quotations Page (hope I got that right…)
posted by
ted
on Friday, Nov 17, 2006
On Faith is a great demonstration of the potential for blogging and the Web in general to get people talking about stuff that actually matters. Yes there’s a lot of junk (read that as “bad design” or “spiritually toxic content”, as you like) out there on the internet. But there is also tremendous potential for bringing people of different viewpoints together to discuss and share and understand one another. I’m adding this one to my Bloglines.
posted by
ted
on Friday, Nov 17, 2006

Arch along the Olympic Coast
Getting perspective is about seeing where you came from, as well as where you’re going. I find this is as true in design as it is in life.
posted by
ted
on Wednesday, Nov 15, 2006
“Only by being made to question our own beliefs can we prevent them from becoming dogma.”
Rob Swan, In Defense of Difficult Clients
posted by
ted
on Tuesday, Nov 14, 2006
Check out BJ Fogg’s Seven steps to institutional innovation. OK, so the page isn’t pretty, but this is good advice. I also highly recommend BJ’s book, Persuasive Technology.
posted by
ted
on Thursday, Nov 09, 2006
Spool on Five Usability Challenges of Web-Based Applications . The case study (Facebook.com) is as interesting as the challenges Spool identifies, which are Scalability, Visual Design, Comprehension, Interactivity, and Change Management.
posted by
ted
on Tuesday, Nov 07, 2006

Mission Beach, San Diego.
The only thing better than creating a beautiful design is watching someone else enjoy it.
posted by
ted
on Monday, Nov 06, 2006
“Not many sites can turn a page upside down and have it make sense, but I think they’ve done it.”
Jamie Cain, speaking of NorthTemple.com
posted by
ted
on Friday, Nov 03, 2006
The Commoditization of HTML, from Snook. For those looking for outsourcing of CSS-based layouts, here’s what looks like a useful list of services. Also check the comments; very entertaining exchange between Jeff Croft and other posters around his comment that “any monkey can bang out XHTML and CSS.” Banana anyone?
posted by
ted
on Thursday, Nov 02, 2006