rob foster archives
Ok, so it’s circa 2002 and I’m watching a new detective show on TV about a guy with OCD. As I ponder how a person can possibly function with so many issues, my mom calls.
“Hi, it’s your mom.”
“Hi Mom.”
“You busy?”
I glance earnestly toward the stream of electrons across the room. “Uh, I guess not.”
“Great, can you help me with a computer thing?”
“Oh, um, sure.”
“Well I just got ‘Word Perfect’ and used it to write a letter to your uncle Jim and now I can’t find it. I think my computer removed it.”
“Oh, well did you look in the recycle bin?”
“Where’s that?”
“It’s on your desktop.”
“On the computer?”
“Yeah. There’s an icon on the desktop called “Recycle Bin.”
“You mean the little picture of the trash can?”
“Yeah, the part of the computer that it sits on is called the ‘Desktop.’” Anyway, double click on the Recycle Bin.”
“Open it up?”
“Yeah.”
“Ok, it’s open.”
“Is anything in there?”
“Yeah, ‘The Internet’ and ‘Setup’ and two little pictures of paper.”
“Ok, does one of those pictures have the name that you gave the letter?”
“I don’t think my letter had a name. It was just a letter I was writing.”
“Mom, why aren’t you using the email I set up for you?”
“I don’t want to use it. It’s too complicated.”
“But I set up an ico… um, one of those little pictures on the desktop for you. All you have to do is open it and click ‘New Message like I showed you.’ I even set up all of your contacts for you. Uncle Jim is in there and everything.”
“I just want help finding the letter I wrote.”
Sigh “Ok, fine… Is ‘Word Perfect’ open now?”
“How do I know that?”
“Well, you know the bar at the bottom of the computer where the ‘Start’ button is?”
“Yeah.”
“Well to the right of it, is there another button on the bar with a picture of a blue circle with a pen in it?”
“No.”
“Is there a button there at all?”
“There’s a picture that looks like a speaker.”
“Huh? No, I mean on the left side of that bar, right next to the ‘Start’ button.”
“What about it?”
“Is there a big button there?”
“Yes.”
“Ok, what does it say?”
“Document one dash Microsoft dot dot dot.”
“Ok, try clicking on that.”
“Oh! There it is! Oh son, you’re so good at this stuff. Thank you!”
“You’re welcome.”
“Ok, goodb… Wait! One more thing. Could you tell me how to get a photo from my new camera into this letter?”
“Oh crap! Mom, I totally forgot I have to go pick up a friend of mine at the airport! Let’s talk later.”
“Ok, well thanks again.”
“Bye.”
Hostage Crisis
At the end of my last article, Erik commented “We’re all suffering from Stockholm Syndrome.” I thought it was a perfect way to describe our relationship with computers.
Those us us who work in tech love our tools with all their complexity. We relish in the fact that we know all the keystrokes for doing every little task in our favorite apps. We are secure in our investment of so much time and energy and effort to learn all the tricks and nuances of our computers.
We fool ourselves by thinking traditional computing is easy.
It isn’t.
Those who malign the Apple iPad for not being more like the computers they’re used to are suffering from a severe case of Stockholm Syndrome.
*Disclaimer: My mother is a smart lady. She has a bachelors from a major university, she’s a leader in her community and now uses computers every day for her job. She’s pretty typical of most non-tech folks I know. And yes, she might read this at some point.
posted by
foster
on Monday, Feb 08, 2010
The darndest thing happened in the last five days and I was fortunate to be privy to it. Apple has gotten people excited about computing.
But this time, it’s not nerds or geeks and certainly not IT industry analysts. It’s everyone else.
I had a curious set of three conversations this week. One with a grandma, one with a technophobe and the third with a self-proclaimed luddite.
Grandma
My mother-in-law walked in the door the day of the keynote and the first thing out of her mouth was “Did you see that new Apple iPad? That looks like it would work for me. Would that work for me?”
I was utterly flabbergasted. She NEVER talks about computers or technology. She tolerates them at best. Her attitude is typical of most baby boomers I’ve talked to regarding computers. She wants to benefit from them but is frustrated by the wall she must climb in order to do so. She’s learned how to use email and a couple of other things on the Internet and that’s about it.
Her bringing up the iPad was amazing for two reasons. First, someone in her office (she works with other ‘boomers) found out about it within hours of the keynote and shared it with her. That Apple news warranted attention from baby boomers at all is significant. That she then held her interest long enough to tell me at the end of the day is equally significant.
After learning a little more information about it, she has decided that she wants an iPad. It actually borders on technolust.
Technophobe
A good friend of mine is an attorney and reluctantly uses technology for his work. In age, he’s somewhere between my generation and the baby boomers. He recently lost his phone in the snow and then found out his company was moving to AT&T. He replaced his lost phone with a blackberry and when our group of friends caught wind of that, we informed him he could have gotten an iPhone. So on our recommendation, he decided to take the Blackberry back and give the iPhone a try.
I had never once seen him exhibit any excitement over technology but the next time I saw him, he could barely contain his enthusiasm for his new phone.
Fast forward to last Wednesday evening. I told him about the new iPad and his eyes grew wide. He blurted out “Wait, are you talking about an iPhone but with a bigger screen? A regular sized computer THIS easy to use? $15 a month for internet anywhere? When can I buy one?”
He had been won over completely by the user experience of the iPhone. It was amazing to watch and fascinating to see him project his good experience and excitement to the iPad.
Luddite
The third conversation came from a completely unexpected source. I have a good friend and neighbor who works remodeling houses and who reluctantly agreed to have me design a website for his company after being pressured by his family. I don’t know anyone else who hates computers more. He has refused to get an email address. He doesn’t use his mobile phone to do anything other than make a call. And he often mocks me anytime I even mention computers. I want to make it perfectly clear that I’m not exaggerating his attitude. At all.
He stopped by my house the day of the keynote to talk about his new website and when he walked in I happened to have some iPad photos open on my laptop. He asked me what they were about and I casually described the new Apple “tablet” that had just been released. I didn’t spend a lot of time on it considering his historical lack of interest in computers. He asked me a couple of questions and then we discussed his site.
Three days later, he called me and the following exchange ensued. “Dude, I think I want to get one of those Apple tablets for my business.” “Really?” I said. “Yeah, I went and looked at them and they seem really easy to use. I think it would work great for showing potential customers my work and for doing bids on.” I was completely speechless.
The Point
After Apple released the iPhone and when the serious rumors started about the “tablet” a year or so ago I had hoped that this was where Apple was going. I’ve long felt that computers were too hard to use, that the filesystem should NEVER be seen by the user. That human-computer interaction should favor the “human” side.
As the Apple guys stood on stage and described the iPad, I knew I was seeing computer history being made. This new approach to computing and experience is as much a game changer as the ORIGINAL Mac. Heck, it may even be more so.
But honestly, before having these three conversations, I figured Apple’s vision would be realized in ten to fifteen years. Now I’m thinking five or less.
One More Thing
When the date for the announcement was set, I started hoping that Apple would release something like iWork for the “tablet.” I doubted they would so soon but the hope was there. As I figured, if they did, they’d be sending a clear message that this was the future of computing, not just for gaming, watching videos and reading books.
Somehow that message has been lost on people (so many iWork comments end with “meh”), but I consider the release of mobile iWork to be the biggest sign of things to come and the strongest message Apple sent regarding their vision for the future.
It’s amazing to watch all of this unfold.
posted by
foster
on Monday, Feb 01, 2010
“There is bad taste and then there is this. What was going through the designer’s mind? ‘I’ll scale it a little bit. Hmmm, maybe just a little more. More. More. I have so much power. I’m drunk in scaling power. More. More. Scale it more. Don’t stop. Do it. Okay, that’s enough.’”
Brand New commentary on the new Microsoft Bing logo
posted by
foster
on Wednesday, Jun 03, 2009

Two awesome modern details from the new Church History Library.
posted by
foster
on Friday, May 15, 2009

The best-selling powered vehicle of all time is now being sold in the US again by the company that manufactured it for 30 years. Up to 153mpg!
posted by
foster
on Friday, May 01, 2009
case study
“Revolution is an idea which has found its bayonets”
- Napoleon Bonaparte
How my search for the right communication device for my disabled daughter led me to an upstart company that was rocking the boat with equal parts love and hate.
Crossing the Threshold
As I mentioned previously, my daughter has cerebral palsy and her condition limits the way she communicates. People always want to know if Ramona is smart and a question we get a lot is “how much does she understand?” I always tell people that we’re not sure just how smart she is, but that we assume she’s a genius, stuck in a broken body.
Many years ago, we started investigating what the disabled community calls “assistive technology.” It’s a formal name for computer-driven products that attempt to improve the lives of people with disabilities. We were looking for a way to help our daughter communicate in our language.
To provide a little context, probably most of you are familiar with Stephen Hawking and have likely heard his monotone, computer-spoken voice. The device he uses is an example of the kind of thing we were looking for.
So we started talking to other parents and therapists to get a consensus on what device was the best out there. We found a company that made a touchscreen product that was supposed to be the best.
It cost $6200.
Six thousand, two hundred dollars.
Suck.
Anyone who lives in this world is more or less used to exorbitant prices for things. Every product is almost a one-off creation, customized to the specific disability of a fraction of the population. I guess we should be lucky any company wants to create products for such a fractional market.
Of course a communication device is a little broader in its appeal since the disabilities that hinder communication are legion. Still, for that much money, I expected a system that was at least moderately easy to use. What we got instead was the ninth circle of Hell.
Dante’s Inferno
I’ve redacted the name of this product, only because it’s been years since this version and maybe it’s gotten better.
Maybe.
Redaction disclaimer aside, I’ve never used a piece of technology worse than this device. I work in IT and have pretty low expectations of most products, but this was the first time I was actually driven to near madness by an inanimate object.

The Beast With Seven Horns
I actually have a difficult time expressing how bad the experience was, so I’ll give you a couple of examples that should do that for me.
For one thing, there was absolutely no consistency in the interface. On each screen, it seemed like the manner in which you saved or committed changes was completely different. It was as if the software was built by developers working from home offices in different countries and who never looked at each others’ work. It made the system labyrinthine and baffling.
Many times, these communication devices lack certain phrases needed for specific real-world situations. Because of this, the option of recording your voice was provided but was so broken that it was unusable. When you recorded your voice, it used so many system resources that it caused the system to slow to a crawl. So we usually opted to use the text-to-speech feature. This meant typing in everything you wanted to say, often in phonetic-style spelling, using a virtual keyboard on a screen that often didn’t register the finger taps. To make it worse, the screen required constant calibration.
When we WERE able to get it to “work,” the computer voice that was provided to our little girl was so cold and robotic, it widened the gap between her and others during casual encounters.
Nobody Expects the Spanish Inquisition
I spent late nights pouring through the five(!) poorly-written manuals, trying to discover how to enable the simplest things. I spent hours of my life I’ll never get back, yelling at this thing as it stared blankly back at me. I’m sure I invoked curses on the developers at least once.

The manual on the bottom is 480 pages long
The pathetic thing is that probably most of the people who buy these products are the parents of kids with disabilities. We’re talking about families with major economic issues, not to mention all the emotional and physical crap that happens in their lives. If I’ve been working with technology for over a decade and I can’t figure it out, what hope do these poor folks have?
Well, we eventually got some demo units of other devices and while not as bad, that’s like saying that hot pokers in your eyes is better than being drawn and quartered. We’re still talking about the Spanish Inquisition.
Even more insulting, the therapists and other folks in this community can’t understand why the parents aren’t completely on board with these products. It’s like they’ve been conditioned that a crap sandwich really doesn’t taste THAT bad.
Hell Hath no Fury Like a Parent Pissed
So it was with skepticism that one day, my wife and I accepted an invitation to be part of a focus study on a product that was being developed by a new company. The guy running the meeting was actually the guy who was starting the company.
Richard Ellenson was a former ad executive and a long-time veteran of Madison Avenue. He had the connections and know-how to put together a team of companies including Frog Design and Nickelodeon to help build and even sponsor the new device. More importantly, he had passion. He hated the existing technology as much or more than we did and he was determined to make it happen. You see, Richard had also spent too many late nights trying to get the same device to work. His son, who also has cerebral palsy was at the age where he desperately needed to be able to communicate.
After meeting with Richard, I was cautiously optimistic that we would actually see a product as good as the prototype he showed us.
Real artists ship
Over a year later, we found out the product had been launched. It was called the “Tango” and was not only everything we saw in the prototype, but so much more.

Here’s a demo of what it’s like to use the Tango.
The voice they chose for the menus not only sounded like a little kid but the device had another trick up its sleeve. If an adult needed to record a phrase for their child, the Tango provides a built-in way of “pitching-up” the recording so it sounds more like a child.
There’s a camera with a flash so the person using it can take pictures of stuff they like. And the battery life on the thing is killer.

Size comparison – 11lbs vs. 1lb
The list of great features is long, but the best thing about it isn’t the feature list. The Tango is impossibly small and light and easy to use. We still haven’t ever cracked open the manual and frankly, I have no idea where the manual even is.
Wait, did we even GET a manual?
And here’s a comparison for you–when my daughter requires specific phrases for a day’s events, my wife is able to configure the Tango while sitting at stoplights on the way to drop her off at school.
Even more importantly, Ramona loves using it.
To further help illustrate how big of a deal the Tango was and is, consider Apple’s iPhone. The leapfrog from the ghetto world of smartphones to the iPhone was huge. If you have an iPhone, you know what I’m talking about.
The jump from the old world of adaptive technology to the Tango was an even bigger deal.
All You Need is Love and/or Hate
So what separates the Tango from everything that preceded it? What about the iPhone?
Passion.
Richard’s love of his son and his hatred of the existing technology drove his passion to create a device that was a couple of orders of magnitude better than anything else out there.
Currently, I’m using a Windows Mobile phone (don’t ask) and I can easily say it’s the second worst piece of software I’ve ever used. Second only to that first communication device Ramona had.
I remember reading somewhere that Steve Jobs and the iPhone team was sick of using crappy phones. Their hatred of what was out there drove their passion to make something that didn’t suck. In fact, in the keynote address where Mr. Jobs introduced the iPhone, he said the following regarding the market at the time: “I hope you never really know how incredible this is… it’s bad out there. This is a revolution of the first order.”
Are either of these devices perfect? No, far from it (I’m holding out for the new Palm Pre myself). But they’re so much better that they make you forget how bad it was before. And it’s so obvious the first time you use them that you wonder why it took so long to get it.
Historic Precedent
Companies are constantly talking about innovation. They all claim to be innovative and the word “revolutionary” is thrown around like a piece of junk mail.
If you look back at history, it becomes clear that most, if not all real revolutions were born out of passion. The American and French revolutions happened because the people were sick of the status quo. They wanted something better. And they were so passionate about it, they were willing to give their lives.
If people really want to create innovative and revolutionary products or services or even cultural changes, they better get some real, honest-to-goodness passion behind it.
Otherwise, is it even worth doing?
Postscript
Alan Kay once said that “People who are really serious about software, should make their own hardware.”
Many people who aren’t familiar with adaptive technology look at this device and think the price tag is too high for what it does. Just check out the comments on this Engadget article to see what I mean.
Here’s a personal favorite of mine:
“Absurd. You could probably pack the entire feature set into a $130 Nintendo DS. Of course, you can’t bill a Nintendo DS to Medicaid. Let’s hope they get NO orders.”
The thing they don’t understand is how non-trivial it is to create a device like this. The Tango is a replacement for someone’s VOICE. The research and development alone is almost prohibitively expensive, not to mention developing a whole new speech system and making the hardware work with switches and other devices already used in the community.
Oh, and if you think making the battery life last for a whole day of speaking is simple–it’s not.
posted by
foster
on Monday, Apr 27, 2009
Dear Designer, You Suck
Fantastic article by Khoi Vinh. I couldn’t agree more with this.
posted by
foster
on Monday, Apr 20, 2009
case study
“Before you criticize someone, you should walk a mile in their shoes. That way when you criticize them, you are a mile away from them and you have their shoes.”
-Jack Handey
PATTERN RECOGNITION
Have you ever considered buying a new car and then started seeing that car everywhere you go? Or perhaps you learned a new word and it seems you started hearing it more than you ever did before?
Cognitive psychologists call this “apophenia.” It describes the way our brain makes connections in random data. It also explains how when we’re presented with any new concept, that concept becomes part of our mental pattern recognition system and begins showing up in our conscious mind.
I’ll get back to apophenia in a minute.
Now, let’s talk about accessibility from an academic perspective. Wikipedia defines the word thusly:
Accessibility is a general term used to describe the degree to which a product (e.g., device, service, environment) is accessible by as many people as possible.
If you work in IT, you may have first heard the concept from a marketing department in your company. In the mid 90’s, the concept was championed largely by corporations, who in their desire for lucrative government contracts, would attempt to adhere to “Section 508 Compliance.” A whole slew of consultants and articles came out of the woodwork, promoting the idea and informing the web development and design community all about this latest buzzword.
Don’t worry, I’m not going to go into Section 508 or the Rehabilitation Act or any of the rest of that stuff. It’s all about politics and has nothing to do with what I’m going to talk about.
Also, I don’t care about any of it.
A DAY IN THE LIFE
The issues of accessibility are a daily reality for my family. For us, it’s not a political issue at all. Our oldest daughter, Ramona, has cerebral palsy and uses a wheelchair to get around.
Allow me to give you a glimpse of what this aspect of our life is like.
Last year, my wife and I took the kids to the Hogle Zoo here in Salt Lake. Before we left, my wife called the information desk to find out if the zoo train was an option for Ramona. Ramona loves to ride on trains.
Anna: “Is the train accessible to wheelchairs?”
The Girl: “Yes.”
Anna: “So how does that work? How do I actually get the wheelchair on the train?”
The Girl: “Well, you take the chair to the edge and then you would lift her out and into the train.”
Anna: “So it’s not wheelchair accessible.”
The Girl: “No, I guess not.”
The girl on the phone had never thought of a real situation. She just had a cursory knowledge of the concept. For her, accessibility was a policy.
A few months ago, Anna called ahead to an Italian restaurant we wanted to visit to find out if we could get inside easily with the wheelchair.
Anna: “Is your restaurant accessible?”
Host: “Yes.”
Anna: “So we won’t have any problem getting a wheelchair inside?”
Host: “Nope.”
So we arrived to the restaurant. I walked up a flight of steps and let the host know we had a wheelchair. He had us meet him at the back entrance where we walked through the kitchen and ran into a very tall step.
Host: “Oh, I guess there IS that one step. Sorry about that.”
Now, I’m a pretty big guy and after 11 years of lifting Ramona and her chair into all kinds of places, one step was not going to keep me from enjoying the evening. I eat steps like that for breakfast. That said, Ramona and her current (non-electric) wheelchair weigh about 170lbs. We’ve looked at electric (power) wheelchairs for her and the low-end from a weight perspective is about 150lbs. If she had a power chair, we would not have been eating baked ziti that night.
There are also a slew of places that are genuinely easy to get the wheelchair into but then the employees place obstacles like sales displays and other things right in the middle of the walkway. Some are worse than others and my wife has a phrase she uses a lot:
“Don’t even think about going antiquing if you’re in a wheelchair.”
-Anna
SPECIES DIFFERENTIATION
I don’t tell these stories because I want sympathy. I don’t share them because I think it makes me a better, smarter, more compassionate person than you. These things are a fact of life for me and my family. And here’s the rub–examples like these and so many others are part of the life of anyone with a disability. In fact, this stuff happens so often that I forget about individual instances unless they’re really funny like the one at the zoo.
It’s not a sob story, but sometimes it really sucks. There are things that my daughter will never be able to do because it’s practically impossible for us to do them. There are rides at the local amusement park she will never be able to ride even though I know she would love them dearly.
Here’s my point–if your brother or sister had a disability, you would give a crap. But you don’t have to have a sibling in a wheelchair to genuinely care, even if it’s only in your work.
Empathy is what separates us from the rest of the animal kingdom. We have an ability to imagine things the way that others see them and how it makes them feel. We don’t even have to have a disability ourselves.
And from my perspective, accessibility is about giving a crap.
Accessibility is NOT a checklist.
Accessibility is about usability.
Accessibility is a paradigm shift.
Accessibility is a personal issue.
WHY IT MATTERS
The odds you’ll ever hear a direct complaint from someone with a disability regarding your work is low. So unless your boss has asked you to care (because your company is going after a government contract) or you have become interested for other professional reasons, you’ll likely never need to care.
You see, the people in the stories I shared are likely very nice, understanding and caring people. They didn’t INTEND to be ignorant about the issues of accessibility, because for them, the reality of the concept didn’t actually exist. It was just a word, a policy, an item on a checklist. And I know this because before I had a child with a disability, I was ignorant too. The whole world of disabilities had not opened to me. And here’s the funny thing–much of it is still closed to me.
Ramona’s disability is just one in a sea of disabilities and every one is different. A few days ago I sat down with a senior gentleman to walk through an application I had designed. As I watched him use the computer, I was starkly reminded of just how hard it is for some senior folks to use the mouse. He doesn’t have the same fine motor control he did when he was 20. Fortunately, I had once taught a course on basic internet skills to a group of seniors and knew how hard some of the things we take for granted can be for them. Because of my understanding, I had made the buttons on the screen fairly large. Because of that knowledge, the application was a success.
This gentleman didn’t have what we typically think of as a disability. Usually, we think about wheelchairs, blindness, missing limbs, etc. But live long enough and disabilities will affect you in one way or another too.
So how then, do we get to where we understand accessibility? How can we internalize it and have a real paradigm shift about what it really means?
My hope with this article is to make accessibility issues surrounding disabilities become real for the reader. The ideal response for me would be for people to think a little harder about the people using your product or experience and what it might be like for those who may not have all their faculties.
MENTAL FLOSS
Ok, so back to apophenia.
I’m going to propose an experiment.
For the next hour or so, I’d like you to imagine you don’t have any hands. All you have are elbows and forearms. How would you scroll down on this article? How would you close the window or switch applications? When you leave your desk and get to a door, what would you do? When you need to eat your lunch, how would you do it? If you get an itch, how would you scratch it? Would you scratch it?
Do a similar exercise next time you think about the experience or product you design.
It seems silly, but putting yourself in someone else’s shoes is liberating. Understanding people and their concerns, needs and wants is a core part of what we do as designers but also helps us to be better people.
And we all want to be better people, right?
posted by
foster
on Tuesday, Mar 24, 2009
Too much dandruff.
posted by foster on Thursday, Jun 17, 2010